I’ve talked about this often enough in the past. (See the “Related posts” list at the end of this one!) But it bears repeating . . . especially if and when it can be said briefly. And I think this is the briefest way I have ever said these things.

What follows is from an interview I did five and a half years ago with the newsletter editor of one of the non-profits we support. I quote his questions and my answers: Read the rest of this entry »

I’ve gotten into some fairly philosophical discussions with our professional legacy planner. As a result, several months ago–I didn’t know at the time whether he was seeking merely to be provocative or whether he was really serious, but–he said he is opposed to ministers who teach the concept of tithing. He said he thinks such teaching holds too many wealthy Christians back from giving more.

Since then, I have come to realize he is actually very serious in the matter. And a month or two ago he sent me a note in which he said he believes “the concept of tithing as taught in the Old Testament does not apply to New Testament Christians in any way and is nowhere endorsed in the New Testament as a basis for giving.”

For some initial food for thought, he said, he thought I would enjoy reading some “very scholarly papers on the subject”: “Will a Man Rob God?” (Malachi 3:8): A Study of Tithing in the Old and New Testaments, Part I and Part II by Andreas Köstenberger and David Croteau.

“I’ll enjoy the dialog with you after you get a chance to digest all this material,” he wrote.

Just what I need–more “material” to digest! I’ve got thousands of books sitting on shelves in front of me still needing to be read!

But this guy impacts a lot of people, and he’s trying to influence me, so I thought I’d better read up on the subject. I finally completed the assignment while on vacation the last couple of weeks, and I wrote back.

I, too, have some severe concerns about tithing, but of a very different nature, I expect, from his. Read the rest of this entry »